Ten Years After the Wall:
Trends in post-Cold War U.S. Security Policy

Charles at Podium
A TWO DAY SYMPOSIUM
was held on
NOVEMBER 11-12, 1999
at the
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
200 Beacon Street
SOMERVILLE, MASSACHUSETTS


Sponsored by:
Project on Defense Alternatives
Commonwealth Institute
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Charles Knight delivers his opening remarks.



Ten years have passed since the inaugurating act of the post-Cold War era--the demolition of the Berlin Wall. The "Ten Years After the Wall" symposium held at the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in Cambridge in November of 1999 examined the questions of how and under what influences U.S. military and security policy has changed during the past decade. More than a simple retrospective, however, speakers looked to the future, assessing the direction of current policy, and then reflected on "the paths not taken."

For each of the topic areas, the questions animating the proceedings were: Where has security policy been in the recent past, where is it going, and why? How well is the U.S. adapting to the challenges and opportunities of the new era? The symposium sought to engage both past choices and present options, paying attention to how the security policy debate has reflected differences over policy goals and priorities, different assumptions about the security environment, and different evaluations of the policy instruments and resources available.

One hundred and forty people attended the symposium, with a majority of the participants students or teachers of security studies and international affairs, leaders of advocacy groups, and other specialists, including military officers and members of the press.

Select Panelist Papers
(in pdf format)


Panel Titles
Panel I:
Panel II: Post-Cold War US Policy on the Role, Use and Utility of Armed Forces
Panel III: Affording Peace: The New Defense Budget Paradox
Panel IV: The Recent Evolution of US Military Posture: Strategy, Missions, Structure
Panel V: The United States and China: Toward a New Cold War?

Program

Thursday, November 11, 1999

Panel I. 1:00-3:30 p.m.
US Security Cooperation: Trends, Problems and Prospects

Amb. Jonathan Dean Janne Nolan Clayton Jones
Amb. Jonathan Dean
Janne Nolan
Clayton Jones
Panelists:
  • Amb. Jonathan Dean, adviser on international security issues, Union of Concerned Scientists; former U.S. Ambassador to the East-West talks on Mutual (and Balanced) Force Reductions;
  • Janne Nolan, director, International Programs, The Century Foundation; former member of the U.S. National Defense Panel;
  • Stephen Walt, professor of international affairs, JFK School of Government, Harvard University.

Moderator: Steven Burg, director, International Studies Program, Department of Politics, Brandeis University.
Interrogator: Clayton Jones, chief editorial writer, Christian Science Monitor.


Panel II. 4:00-6:30 p.m.
Post-Cold War US Policy on the Role, Use and Utility of Armed Force
Robert Art Carl Kaysen James Carroll Steven Miller
Robert Art
Carl Kaysen
James Carroll
Steven Miller
Panelists:
  • Robert Art, director of graduate studies, Department of Politics, Brandeis University;
  • Carl Kaysen, chair, Committee on International Security Studies, American Academy of Arts & Sciences; Security Studies Program, MIT;
  • Steve Van Evera, professor of political science, Security Studies Program, MIT.

Moderator: Steven Miller, director, International Security Program, JFK School of Government, Harvard University.
Interrogator: James Carroll, columnist, Boston Globe.


Friday, November 12, 1999

Panel III. 10:00 a.m.-12:00 p.m.
Affording Peace: The New Defense Budget Paradox
Crowd Shot
Attendees listen to
Cindy Williams

Panelists
:
  • Randall Forsberg, director, Institute for Defense & Disarmament Studies;
  • Cindy Williams, senior fellow, Security Studies Program, MIT; former Assistant Director, Congressional Budget Office.

Moderator: Charles Knight, co-director, Project on Defense Alternatives, Commonwealth Institute.
Interrogator: Paul Tooher, editor, Global Beat Syndicate; assistant managing editor, Providence Journal.


Panel IV. 1:00-3:30 p.m.
The Recent Evolution of US Military Posture: Strategy, Missions, Structure
Alan Berger
Alan Berger
Panelists:
  • Carl Conetta, co-director, Project on Defense Alternatives, Commonwealth Institute;
  • Stuart Johnson, senior scientist, Rand Corporation;
  • Barry Posen, professor of political science, Security Studies Program, MIT.

Moderator: Charles Knight, co-director, Project on Defense Alternatives, Commonwealth Institute.
Interrogator: Alan Berger, editorial writer, Boston Globe.


Panel V. 4:00-6:45 p.m.
The United States and China: Toward a New Cold War?
China Panel Thomas J. Christensen Lee Sigal
China Panel
Thomas J. Christensen
Lee Sigal
Panelists:
  • Robert Ross, professor of political science, Boston College;
  • Paul Heer, visiting fellow, Council on Foreign Relations;
  • James Nolt, senior fellow, World Policy Institute;
  • Thomas J. Christensen, professor of political science, MIT.

Moderator: Sarah Sewall, associate director, Committee on International Security Studies, American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
Interrogator: Lee Sigal, consultant, Social Science Research Council


This symposium was made possible by grants from the Ford Foundation and the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.

Special thanks to the members and staff of the Committee on International Security Studies, American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the Security Studies Program at the Center for International Studies, MIT.

[PDA Home] [About PDA] [New At This Site] [Chinese Military Power Page] [Publications] [Links] [Search This Site] [E-mail PDA]

The Project on Defense Alternatives, The Commonwealth Institute
P.O. Box 398105, Inman Square Post Office, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Phone: 617/547-4474, Fax: 617/868-1267, email: pda@XXREMOVE_BEFORE_SENDINGXX-comw.org

This page created and maintained by Aaron Katz
Copyright© The Commonwealth Institute. All Rights Reserved.